Rusty Nail: Two Ingredients and a Name in Search of a Home
Scotch and Drambuie over ice, and that is it. The drink is simple, but its road to the name “Rusty Nail” was long and confused.
- Era: 1930s to 1960s; name from 1963
- Origin: Britain / New York (disputed)
- Created by: Unknown
- Family: Spirit-forward (two-ingredient)
The pairing of Scotch with Drambuie, a liqueur of whisky, honey and herbs, went by several names before one stuck. Wikipedia links an early version to the 1937 British Industries Fair, though other sources do not confirm it. In 1951 Ted Saucier’s book listed a similar drink called the Little Club No. 1. Bartender and historian Dale DeGroff credits the familiar version to the bartenders of Manhattan’s 21 Club in the early 1960s.
The name “Rusty Nail” is usually tied to 1963, when Gina MacKinnon, chair of the Drambuie company, endorsed it and it stuck. Why a rusty nail? Nobody knows for sure; the common explanation is the drink’s copper colour, but that is a guess. In the 1960s and 70s it became associated with Frank Sinatra and Dean Martin’s Rat Pack, though how closely is hard to document.
The ratio varies widely: from 1:1, which is very sweet, to 2:1 or even 4:1 in favour of the whisky, which is where most bars sit today. It is on the IBA “Unforgettables” list. With only two ingredients, both alcoholic, it is a genuinely strong drink, best sipped slowly.
Bartender’s tip: build it straight in the glass over one large cube and stir for just a few seconds. A lemon twist expressed over the top adds freshness that balances the honey. If it tastes too sweet, simply cut back on the liqueur; if you want smoke, choose a smokier Scotch as the base.
Fun fact: Scottish tradition links Drambuie to Prince Charles Edward Stuart, “Bonnie Prince Charlie”, who legend says gave the recipe to a Scottish family after the failed 1745 rising. It is a family legend that is hard to verify.