Planter's Punch: one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak
Jamaica's rum punch leans on an old rhyme that teaches exactly how to build it.
- Era: 19th century; the rhyme documented in the early 20th century
- Origin: Jamaica
- Created by: Unknown
- Family: Punch / Tropical
Punch itself is one of the oldest mixed drinks in the Western world: British sailors and clerks brought it back from India as early as the 17th century, and in the Caribbean it naturally met rum. Planter's Punch is tied above all to Jamaica, but it has no known inventor. Another story says the name comes from the Planters Hotel in Charleston in the American South, though most historians see that as unproven.
The classic formula rests on a rhyme: 'one of sour, two of sweet, three of strong, four of weak', that is lime, sugar, rum and water or ice. The rhyme was printed in the American press in the early 20th century, and mentions of such a punch go back earlier. Over the years every bar added its own touch: orange juice, pineapple, grenadine, nutmeg.
In the tiki world of the 1930s and 1940s, Planter's Punch was the base for countless variations, and Don the Beachcomber himself offered several. The IBA lists it among its 'Unforgettables', with a recipe close to the old Jamaican formula plus bitters.
Bartender's tip: the 'weak' in the rhyme matters as much as the 'strong'. Dilution is part of the recipe, not a flaw. Shake with ice and strain into a tall glass over fresh ice, or build and stir. Dark Jamaican rum gives the deep, fruity character the drink is known for, and it is also high in alcohol, so this is a long drink to sip slowly.
Fun fact: historians often quote the same rhyme as one of the oldest ways of teaching cocktail ratios, long before bars had measuring jiggers.