Mai Tai: the great feud of the tiki world
Jamaican rum, lime, curaçao and orgeat. One drink, two inventors claiming the crown, and a name that means 'excellent'.
- Era: 1944
- Origin: Trader Vic's, Oakland, California
- Created by: Victor 'Trader Vic' Bergeron (rival claim by Donn Beach)
- Family: Tiki
The accepted version says Victor 'Trader Vic' Bergeron created the Mai Tai in 1944 at his bar in Oakland, California. By his account he served it to friends from Tahiti, who exclaimed 'maita'i roa ae', roughly 'very good, the best' in Tahitian, and that gave the drink its name. Another story comes from Don the Beachcomber, who claimed the Mai Tai was a copy of his Q.B. Cooler from 1933. The two drinks are quite different, and most historians credit Trader Vic with the familiar recipe.
Vic's original was built on a particular 17-year-old Jamaican rum that ran out within a few years because the drink was so popular. He moved to blends of Jamaican and Martinique rum, which is still the base of most serious recipes. In 1953 the drink reached hotels in Hawaii, and from there it spread worldwide.
From the 1960s to the 1980s, as the 'Mai Tai' spread through resort and hotel menus, it picked up pineapple juice, orange juice and grenadine, turning into a sweet fruit punch where the original is barely recognisable. Elvis Presley serves Mai Tais in Blue Hawaii (1961). The IBA lists it among its official cocktails.
Bartender's tip: orgeat, an almond syrup, is the secret heart of the drink. Use a good orgeat, not a synthetic 'almond' syrup. Shake briefly with crushed ice, dump everything into the glass, and garnish with a mint sprig and a spent lime shell, which Vic said should look like a small island with a palm tree.
Fun fact: trademarks, lawsuits and accusations between the two men went on for years, and Vic wrote sharply about anyone who claimed to have made the drink before him.