Illegal: Mezcal, Rum and Falernum from Northern Italy
A smoky, spiced sour that joined the IBA list in 2020. Its origin story leads, of all places, to a hotel bar in Italy.
- Era: Late 1990s (per one account)
- Origin: Northern Italy (per one account)
- Created by: Samuele Ambrosi (per an Italian source; not independently confirmed)
- Family: Sour
The Illegal's history is less documented than most official cocktails, and some specialist sites list its origin as unknown. According to a piece in the Italian bar magazine MixologyItalia, Italian bartender Samuele Ambrosi created it in the late 1990s at the bar of the Castel Brando hotel in northern Italy, as a Daiquiri-style drink with tequila, Jamaican rum and falernum. In that story an American guest said it tasted “so good it must be illegal,” and the name stuck.
Later, the same account says, Ambrosi swapped tequila for mezcal, and it is that updated recipe that entered the IBA official list in 2020 in the New Era category: espadín mezcal, strong white Jamaican rum, falernum, a barspoon of maraschino, lime, simple syrup and, optionally, a little egg white.
Structurally it is a classic sour with tiki layers: falernum, a Caribbean syrup of lime, ginger, clove and almond, and the Jamaican rum bring the tropical side, while mezcal brings smoke.
Bartender's tip: if using egg white, shake first without ice (a dry shake) to build foam, then again with ice. Note that the Jamaican rum in the recipe is overproof, so the drink is stronger than the foam and lime suggest and is best sipped slowly.