Between the Sheets: the Sidecar That Got Rum Too
Brandy, rum, orange liqueur and lemon: an interwar cocktail whose origin is disputed.
- Era: 1920s-30s
- Origin: Paris or London (disputed)
- Created by: uncertain (usually credited to Harry MacElhone)
- Family: Sour / Sidecar
Between the Sheets is a direct relative of the Sidecar: the same frame of brandy, orange liqueur and lemon, with white rum added. Several stories explain where it came from. The most common one credits Harry MacElhone at Harry's New York Bar in Paris in the 1930s. Another places it at the Berkeley hotel in London around 1921. There is also a folk tale about French brothels, with no documentation to back it up.
The name belongs to the 1920s and 1930s habit of cheeky, attention-grabbing drink names. Structurally it is a strong drink: three parts spirit and liqueur against one part lemon. Later cocktail books changed the ratios, and some versions use less liqueur and more lemon to balance the sweetness. Today it is listed by the IBA among its Unforgettables.
Bartender's tip: with two base spirits the balance is delicate. A light white rum adds freshness; a dark rum will bury the cognac. Freshly squeezed lemon is a must; shake well and serve in a chilled cocktail glass with an orange or lemon twist. If you find it too sweet, pull back a little on the orange liqueur.
Fun fact: for all its suggestive name, most stories about its birth remain hearsay. The drink itself is a good example of the French-British family of orange-liqueur sours, of which the Sidecar is the patriarch.